The Repubs’ latest fabrication is that Roosevelt himself personally endorsed private accounts, and presumably the cuts in benefits that go with them.
According to Roosevelt’s grandson, James Roosevelt Jr., who is a former Associate Commissioner on Social Security, the quote was taken completely out of context. Keith Olbermann had him on the show to clear things up. The two of them go over the quote in question with a fine-toothed comb and provide the larger context in which it appears.
(see below for full quote within context)
Even a simple reading of the quote makes it clear that Roosevelt envisioned private accounts in addition to regular benefits, for those who could afford to invest in them, so they would have additional benefits later. (Not as a replacement for the current system.)
Video – Keith Olbermann and Roosevelt’s Grandson Call Bush Roosevelt Claim A Fraud (14 MB)
Audio – Keith Olbermann and Roosevelt’s Grandson Call Bush Roosevelt Claim A Fraud (MP3 – 9 MB)

Transcription:
President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, father to the New Deal and, at minimum, mid-wife to the Social Security system, would have endorsed President Bush’s plan to partially privatize it. Our third story of the countdown, that is the claim anyway of at least three conservative commentators and several Republican congressman, but it turns out, those guys pretty much just made it up…
At the risk of doing a little too much reading, just to put it on the historical record, let me read the entire quote from which those quotes were pulled (portion of quote misused by Brit Hume and others is in italics):
“In the important field of security for our old people, it seems necessary to adopt three principles. First, non-contributory old age pensions for those who are now too old to build up their own insurance. It is of course clear that perhaps 30 years to come funds will have to be provided by the States and the Federal Government to meet these pensions. Second, compulsory contributory annuities which in time will establish a self-supporting system for those now young and for future generations. Third, voluntary contributory annuities by which individual initiative can increase the annual amount received in old age. It is proposed that the Federal Government assume one-half of the cost of the old-age pension plan, which ought ultimately to be supplanted by self-supported annuity plans.”
Sign Up For My Notification List
Hey, I just upgraded to a new Movable Type version, and I see I have email notification list capabilities now. So any of you who want to be on it, send me an email at lisarein@finetuning.com.
thanks,
lisa
Rumsfeld On Meet the Press – February 6, 2005
This is from the February 6, 2005 program of Meet the Press.
Update 2/8/05: I’ve broken it down into 2 halfs, and made MP3s of it
I still have to break this down into smaller clips, but I wanted to make complete video and audio available for press folks and things that might need it asap.
Basically, Tim Russert is ruthless with the flinging of the fact.
Rummy loses it a couple time, although he quickly recovers. He admits that he may have “mis spoke” a couple times, and disregards those facts and figures that he wasn’t prepared to respond to.
I will be putting up smaller clips and better analysis soon, promise.
For now, this stuff is here:
Video Of Rumsfeld On Meet The Press
Check Out The Latest Wide Hive Release: Plate Fork Knife Spoon
Our latest release at Wide Hive is Plate Fork Knife Spoon. It’s basically the Crown City Rockers’ rhythm section with Eric Krasno from Soulive on guitar and David Boyce from the Brown Fellinis on Sax.
Crown City emcee Raashan Ahmad guests on one track, Wonder.
(MP3 – 6 MB). It’s my favorite track on the record.
Give it a listen…
Wonder is only available on the CD and 12″ (not the LP. The 12″ also contains an Exclusive beat, “Sabado.”
Joe Klein On The Daily Show – The Shrub’s Social Security Plan Explained
This is from the February 3, 2005 program.
In this clip, Time magazine’s Joe Klein talks about the State of the Union address and the truth behind the Shrub’s Social Security overhaul: it’s all about benefit cuts, not increased payments due to shrewd investment of private accounts.
Joe Klein On The Daily Show (Small – 12 MB)
Audio of Joe Klein On The Daily Show (MP3 – 8 MB)
Joe Klein:
Here’s the cool thing about Social Security. Yesterday, before the speech, the White House explains it the “torters,” the private investment accounts, and here’s the way it works:
You put your money in your own private investment account. And then, when it’s time for you to retire, you give a whole lot of it back to the government so that they can dribble out little benefits to you that are the equivalent of Social Security as it now stands.
Jon Stewart:
That’s really what this plan is?
Joe Klein:
If you make more than a designated amount, you might get a little bit extra. Yes.
Jon Stewart:
That’s it?
Joe Klein:
It’s an annuity.
Jon Stewart:
But here’s what I don’t understand…
Joe Klein:
It’s really remarkable.
Jon Stewart:
But how does that save Social Security? Because the government still has to dish out the same amount of money, no?
Joe Klein:
Well, they’re going to lower our benefits it was they’re gonna actually do, and the President said he would last night.
Shrub Prepares To Cut Funding To Those That Need It Most
Bush to Propose Billions in Cuts
Farm subsidies and food stamps are among the targets in the 2006 budget plan, to be sent to Congress on Monday. Opposition is building.
By Joel Havemann and Mary Curtius For The LA Times.
President Bush will propose a 2006 budget Monday that, despite record spending of about $2.5 trillion, will call for billions of dollars in cuts that will touch people on food stamps and farmers on price supports, children under Medicaid and adults in public housing…
In addition to the cuts proposed in the 2006 budget, Bush is expected to ask Congress to approve in principle many billions of dollars in additional, unspecified cuts…
The lower-income Americans who benefit from food stamps and Medicaid do not typically provide the Republican Party with many votes or campaign contributions.
The proposed budget will give states less flexibility to include working poor families with children as beneficiaries, sources said.
Can Anyone Help Me Find The Lyrics Born-U2 Mash-up?
Update 2/7/05 – found it! It’s called
Callin On Sunday by Party Ben. thanks guys!
I heard a mash-up of Lyric Born’s “Calling Out” and U2’s “Sunday Bloody Sunday” the other day on San Francisco’s Live 105.
I want to hear it again, but it doesn’t seem to be anywhere. Can you guys help me out?
It’s cool to hear Lyrics Born blowin up on Live 105. It reminds me to plug our
DJ Zeph 12″ (and CD) that features Lyrics Born:
Hands Up. (MP3 – 5 MB)
You can also buy it on iTunes.
Haven’t Checked Email All Week
Hey I got busy this week and kinda didn’t check mail all week.
I’m just going through it now.
So if you wrote me a letter and I didn’t respond. That’s why. I’m catching up now.
I love to hear from you guys, so I didn’t want you to think I wasn’t writing back.
talk soon!
lisa
Daily Show On Wal-Mart – Learn Fun Facts From Jon
This is from the January 20, 2005 program.
In this segment, we get to learn lots of fun facts about Wal-Mart. Like how they call a 28 hour week “full time.” And how the company has recently launched a huge PR campaign to try to combat the numerous lawsuits and bad press its been getting lately.
Daily Show On Wal-Mart (Small – 6 MB)
Audio – Daily Show On Wal-Mart (MP3 – 3 MB)

DVD Stuck In My CD Tray – OSX Can’t Even See My Player Anymore
Update 1:55 pm: A reader suggested I turn my machine off for a minute, then restarted holding down the “C” key so it would try to boot from the disc, when it didn’t find the system disc it was looking for, it asked me if I wanted to eject it.
Turns out that Mac drivers don’t get blown away (like PC drivers can), but they can sort of get “forgotten” till the system does a sort of check and kicks them back in.
Thanks again for being such great readers that always seem to be willing to help me out when I get stuck. What would I do without ya 🙂
Hey guys, Tech support question here.
I put in a DVD and was trying to use utilities to burn an image and make a copy, when (all of a sudden…pow!) no seriously, it wasn’t quite that exciting, but it is holding me up on a number of projects now: my dual G4 can’t see the Superdrive.
How do I reinstall the drivers? I tried to eject it from the firmware and reboot holding down the mouse and all the stuff that “help” suggests. I googled till I was blue in the face, and now I ask for your wisdom to save the day.
Thanks in advance for emailing me at lisarein@finetuning.com with a possible solution.
lisa